The Kaleidoscope of Stigma: Reflections & Responses By R.J. Barna (7/1/2023)

Stigma looks different depending on your perspective: who you are, how you were raised, and what your community and cultural values may be. We know that it’s persistent. We also know that experiences with behavioral health stigma intersect with others (stigma based on age, race, gender identity, etc.), compounding them into harmful situations as diverse and complex as we are. It can be challenging to identify stigma, its sources, and the scope of its impact. Developing effective and accessible stigma solutions can be all the more so.

With this in mind, we interviewed several individual attendees of On Our Own of Maryland’s 2023 Annual Conference about their thoughts on stigma. We “turned the kaleidoscope” in hopes of finding stigma solutions and strategies for positive change, inside and out. We refocused and looked again, and what we found was a mosaic of perspectives on choice, voice, and alternatives with hope at its heart.

Stigma persists

For all the positive change the Anti-Stigma Project has seen over 30 years working with healthcare providers, peer organizations, faith-based organizations, judges, students, law enforcement personnel, departments of social services, and many others, our work is far from over. As Denise Camp put it, stigma persists, “by not seeing us as individuals and seeing us as a diagnosis.” She said that, “I, myself, went to a doctor’s office complaining about some physical issue. He saw the [psychiatric] medications I was on and just wrote me off – left me in the room for an hour and a half – and only came back in the room because he left his pen.”

When others treat us like we are unimportant, less than, or just a diagnosis, we can internalize these concepts and lose our sense of self: who we are and what we are capable of doing. As Dr. Alicia Luckstead explained during the conference, “stigmatization is a social process” or “social pollution”; “through media, cultural saturation, institutions, laws, [and] information consumption, stigma becomes internalized and accepted as ‘normal.’” We may then project this sense (and the accompanying sense of ‘abnormal’) onto others and their situations, continuing the cycle of stigma.

Stigma looks different

Stigma presents itself through the language we use and the ways we treat ourselves and others. It would be nice if there were simple rules to follow, but we know it’s not that easy. As Sean Driscoll said, “I think it just comes down to … understanding that not everyone goes through the same things,” continuing, “conversation is the starter for [ending stigma], right? We have to get out of our comfort zone a little bit and start conversations with people that might [look] completely different than how we look, and we might already have our preconceived notions without even getting to learn who they are.”

Education helps

We can learn from our own experiences. Interviewee Robert VanDyke shared that his decision to discontinue medication with negative side effects was an important part of his recovery journey. It was then he, “noticed there’s a lot of stigma coming from the situation about medication.” Even though treatments may work for some and providers may have good intentions, it’s important that we have space to reflect on our own experience and choose our own treatments, especially if they are resulting in negative outcomes.

Adelaide Weber also championed self-education, saying, “we really need to educate ourselves on recognizing that language does matter. Making sure that we are aware of what we are saying and how we say things, and then, if we hear something, we should – we ought to – be brave enough to have a conversation with somebody else and right the wrongs. I think it’s worth doing, because there could be times where an individual may not be aware that what they’re saying is hurtful.”

Starting with the self

Bryan Johnson suggested that changing stigma starts with, “looking in the mirror; it starts with yourself.” This aligns with a commonly recognized theory of human development by Jacques Lacan, the Mirror Stage, during which we come to know who we are – and who and what we are not – by recognizing our reflection in the mirror. A good place to start looking for solutions can be from the position that we are all works in progress.

Starting with the self doesn’t always mean going it alone. Another side to Lacan’s theory of self-discovery is that self-awareness may come through our reflection in the behaviors of those around us. According to Jackie Pettis, “I think the power and importance of having peer-run spaces is that it opened my eyes to a whole different world of how to experience having a diagnosis. I was introduced to a world where people are talking about it in an empowering way. I think advocacy is something that I am, [because as I] became more passionate about [it, it] helped with my self-stigma.”

Solutions that offer choice, voice, and alternatives

We’ve long known through experience and research that collaborative relationships reduce stigma, and yet, finding a voice in one’s own recovery remains difficult. According to Shira Collings, “It’s a very coercive process often where people are locked up and they’re told they have to take certain medications to get out or undergo certain treatments.”

Shira continued, stating that solutions need to start with, “many more alternatives to coercive mental health services. I think too often people who are in crisis and really struggling and who just want support and help and compassion and just a human-to-human connection are instead met with an immediate response of taking away their autonomy, taking away their rights, [and] sending them to a psychiatric hospital where they feel alienated and isolated and away from family and friends who could be supports.”

Solutions have hope at heart

Shira concluded that, “a world without stigma would just be us acknowledging [the needs and harms of the current behavioral health situation] and validating that and coming together to be with each other around that instead of labeling each other or taking away rights from each other or excluding each other based on that.” Coming together, establishing equitable relationships, seeing ourselves and others as unique and our situations as ever-changing presents opportunities for solutions.

We can create new patterns for positive change by considering the full spectrum of intersectional perspectives of those around us. We keep turning the kaleidoscope with intention and hope that the next pattern will look better than the last. Sometimes for ourselves, and sometimes for others. Like Laurie Galloway said, “you have to have hope. I think I’ve had people come into my center and say to me, thank God you had hope, because I didn’t have any, and I need somebody to believe in me. I think we just can’t stop doing that.”