It’s hard to talk about gaming without mentioning stigma. Stigmatizing behaviors and attitudes – those that shame, devalue, and discriminate against others based on preconceived notions – are often experienced in game content and communities. Games often lack diverse or fair representation and feature biased messaging and situations. Game communities overflow with sexism, racism, ageism, sexual prejudice, and other abuses fueled by stigma. This has led many to prejudge gamers as toxic and games as unhealthy, although research consistently demonstrates most gamers do not align with toxic acts or messaging, and there are measurable benefits to gaming. Gameplay provides opportunities for understanding the self, support through positive gamer relationships, personal development, and therapeutic recovery.
Stigmatizing Games and Gamers
Stigma usually plays out like this: people think what they and the people around them do is right. Knowingly or unknowingly, this also suggests that what few people do differently is wrong and even shameful. The early days of gaming followed this pattern, with many adults looking down on games and the few who played them, but a lot has changed. Today, almost 64% of people in the U.S. play video games, 56% are ages 34 or younger, and 48% are female (Clement). Although more than half of the population now play video games, “as few as 20% identify themselves as gamers,” likely stemming from, “persistent, pejorative stereotypes,” – such as that games are only for boys or that gamers who enjoy violent games are violent, for example – and lingering perspectives that fail to acknowledge diverse player identities (Schrage).
A 2021 study found that representation in games is still predominantly male (79.9% of video game characters) and white (75.3%). Four out of five male characters display “traditionally masculine behavior” and less than 1% of characters are identified as LGBT+ (Moonshot News).
Inclusivity efforts in gaming like including optional character customization tools or diverse secondary characters often make news due to criticism from a small number of voices. Recently, Sims 4 – a social simulation game in which players create digital people and observe and play their digital lives – released free updates allowing players to adjust pronouns and attire, and added, “inclusive character creation options like hearing aids, glucose monitors, binders, and top surgery scars” (Litchfield). The change was criticized by a vocal few (mostly non-gamers), but the player-base actually grew during this time, reaching 70 million players worldwide by April of 2023 (EA). This suggests that a silent majority is willing to support projects that embrace inclusion.
Toxicity in Games and Communities
A similar situation exists in online play and gaming communities. A 2023 study of first-person shooter (FPS) games like Call of Duty reported that although over 50% of players saw or experienced a rise in toxic or untoward behavior online, the majority of multiplayer gamers said, “they’re likely to leave a game if they encounter a player ruining the experience for them” (Dowd). Because few report abuse, choosing instead to block, mute, or otherwise avoid it, the harmful attitudes and behaviors persist, often targeting others on the basis of race, age, sexuality, or gender.
Although female players make up almost half of U.S. gamers, they experience disproportionate levels of hostility during play. A 2016 survey found that as few as 7.2% of FPS gamers were women, yet 77%, “report[ed] dealing with unwanted behavior” (Fishman). This can be the result of stigmatizing assumptions and projections regarding “girl gamers,” suggesting they don’t belong or lack value, and this messaging is echoed in game content. Female characters are, “almost five times more likely to be shown with some level of nudity,” “ten times more likely to be shown in revealing clothing,” and, “far more likely to be visually or verbally sexually objectified than male characters (3.5% compared with 0.1%)” (Moonshot). Still, female players are flourishing and make up almost a third of all FPS gamers today.
Assumptions, Misconceptions, and Realities
A common assumption about games is that they are dangerous. While there are risks of too much gaming like carpal tunnel or “gamer’s thumb,” experts generally agree it is not harmful in moderation and promotes heightened reflexes and critical thinking. A 2022 Oxford study also found that, “gaming does not appear harmful to mental health, unless the gamer can’t stop.”
The reality is that there are numerous benefits to gaming and game communities, even if risk is present. Game designer Jane McGonigal outlined some incredible effects of gaming, ranging from preventing memories associated with post-traumatic stress disorder by playing Tetris, to pain relief “in the most severe burn cases by 30–50%, which is more effective than morphine.” Video game play increased in response to the COVID-19 pandemic – enabling isolated players to safely connect and build relationships around common interests – and remains full of other wellness possibilities.
And although toxic spaces and stigmatizing messages exist in gaming, the majority of gamers consistently play and seek out inclusive and supportive experiences.
Exploration of Self and Personal Development
Identifying with a character in simulated experiences can help players learn about themselves and how to effectively interact with the real world. Role playing games (RPGs), whether played on a console or around a table like Dungeons & Dragons, have been used by therapeutic game masters (the person running each game through a trauma-informed lens) and licensed clinical professional counselors for years as a safe space to roleplay scenarios and explore feelings and intentions. Temporarily hindered by stigmatizing attitudes of the 1980s that painted D&D players as basement-dwelling devil-worshippers, current practices produce positive outcomes like improved communication skills, boundary-setting, and self-esteem in players and self-efficacy in resisting substance addiction in youth (Karatay & Gurarslan Bas).
In Recovery and Therapy
Games have been, “used to treat conditions such as depression, anxiety, PTSD, and addiction,” when played alongside a therapist (Bocci, et al.). Solo play in a game like Animal Crossing: New Horizons could also be considered therapeutic due to its calming music, relaxed gameplay, and charming character interactions, and many fans (including myself) credit the title for helping relieve stress during the pandemic. Games like Minecraft and Roblox even, “allow us to uncover how our leadership and organization skills are married with curiosity and exploration,” opening, “avenues [that] allow us to feel hopeful, an emotion that is important for growth” (Landrum).
It may seem counterintuitive, but violent FPS games could also aid recovery, according to a 2018 study of veterans and video games. For some, “video games and especially virtual reality … meant to simulate battlefield conditions as a form of prolonged exposure therapy,” has been useful as, “one of the two main psychotherapies offered by VA to treat veterans with PTSD, along with cognitive processing therapy” (Richman).
Stigma at Play
Stigma plays out differently in gaming than in other settings, with data showing a majority of players reject “othering” behavior and welcome inclusion. Still, effective strategies for stigma reduction remain the same: awareness, education, and contact. Being aware of the impact of harmful behaviors, and knowing they aren’t alone, could embolden some to stand up to stigma and report abusers. Sharing educational resources debunks tired prejudgments and suggests evidenced alternatives for wellness. Building positive relationships, getting in closer contact – even digitally – with other gamers and yourself, could help delete stigma in gaming and provide a powerful tool for recovery and behavioral health.
References for Stigma at Play
Bocci, F., Ferrari, A., & Sarini, M. (2023). Putting the gaming experience at the center of the therapy-the video game therapy approach. Healthcare.
Clement, J. (2023). Topic: Video gaming in the United States. Statista.
Clement, J. (2023). U.S. shooter gaming audiences by gender 2023. Statista.
Dowd, T. (2023). Toxic behavior is worsening in online games-and players are increasingly losing patience. The Messenger.
EA. (2023). We inspire the world to play. Electronics Arts.
Fishman, Andrew. (2022). Women in gaming: A difficult intersection. Psychology Today.
Gaming does not appear harmful to mental health, unless the gamer can’t stop. University of Oxford. (2022).
Heal your brain with video games: Jane McGonigal. YouTube. (2017).
Karatay and Gurarslan Bas. (2017). Effects of role-playing scenarios on the self-efficacy of students in resisting against substance addiction: A pilot study. Inquiry : a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing.
Landrum, Ariel L. (2020). Therapeutic gameplay in Animal Crossing. Guidance Teletherapy.
Moonshot News. (2023). Gender stereotypes keeping women away from online gaming - study.
Richman, Mike. Study: Video games can help Veterans recover from mental health challenges. (2019).
Schrage. (2021). Study makes case for importance of “gamer” identity. Nebraska Today. University of Nebraska–Lincoln.

