An Historical Perspective …
In 1993, information emerged from New York indicating that consumers of mental health services felt more stigmatized within the mental health system than outside of it. Armed with this disconcerting news, the Maryland Mental Hygiene Administration (MHA) decided to examine this issue within Maryland’s Public Mental Health System. Two MHA staff, Jim Stockdill, Deputy Director and Alison Carter, Program Administrator spearheaded this project for the department. A committee of 25 individuals was selected that included consumers, family members, advocates, providers (of all kinds— psychiatrists, social workers, nurses, etc.) and administrators.
Stockdill and Carter decided that this committee should be co-chaired by a consumer and a provider. John Allen, Executive Director of a unique consumer-run program in Montgomery County and T. E. Arthur, Executive Director of a Psychiatric Rehabilitation Program in Baltimore City, were asked to take on this challenge. The stated purpose for this committee was to develop a method of examining and addressing the issue of stigma within the Maryland Public Mental Health System. The 25 individuals were chosen specifically because of their reputation and experience as consumer advocates, family advocates and/or consumer-oriented professionals.
Once the first meeting was scheduled, Allen and Arthur met to explore ideas and potential strategies that the committee might use to achieve its purpose. Naively, Allen and Arthur assumed that their “great leadership” would produce a report or product within 6 to 8 committee meetings. However, the very first committee meeting provided an opportunity to learn some of the very first lessons about stigma:
that stigma is a very complex and complicated issue
that intense feelings about stigma were prevalent among all committee members, and
that committee members experienced stigma in different ways
Looking at Ourselves…
During the early meetings, it became very evident that stigma was not only alive and well in the mental health community at large, but also within the committee itself. However, being committed to this process of discovery and self-examination, the members soon began to confront each other about what they perceived to be stigmatizing statements, attitudes or behaviors. This open confrontation was not simply an issue between consumers and providers; rather, it was a matrix from which no one was exempt.
Consumers talked of being stigmatized by family members, and also by each other. Family members talked of being stigmatized by both providers and consumers. Interdisciplinary stigma was discussed—for example, the preconceived assumptions between a psychiatrist and a social worker. That was the beginning of another important lesson: that stigma was not just a “consumer against provider” issue. Stigmatizing attitudes and behaviors were universal and practiced and experienced by every member of the Anti-Stigma Project Committee. While this indeed was a painful discovery, it fortunately provided the impetus and environment for attitudinal and behavioral change to ultimately occur. Through intense self-exploration, awareness, and confrontation, the playing field became level and a sense of trust, acceptance and caring was created among the committee members. Members were able to openly experience and share with each other the feelings of being stigmatized—and of stigmatizing others. It wasn't easy … many tears were shed, many voices were raised, and many feelings were hurt. However, as the layers were uncovered, the members were able to relate to each other as people rather than as roles or labels.
After approximately 8 or 9 months of meetings, of dialoguing and sharing ideas about this complex topic of stigma, a retreat was held. Utilizing the services of Naomi Booker Associates, the committee began to crystallize its mission, objectives and action steps. Following this retreat, the committee began to explore and discuss ways to accomplish the goal for which the committee had been established, which was to develop a report or product to address stigma within Maryland’s Public Mental Health System. In 1994, through funding from the Mental Hygiene Administration, On Our Own of Maryland was able to hire a Director for the project, namely Jennifer Brown.
A Workshop Is Born …
Realizing that we had stumbled upon a way to create concrete attitudinal and behavioral change—particularly since it came about among people who didn't initially see that they needed to change at all—the group anxiously wanted to find a way to share it with the rest of the mental health system. At this point, the group started brainstorming about a possible workshop and loosely designed several formats, tried them out, and finally came up with a model they thought would work. A videotape was put together, compiled of snippets of interviews with folks about their experiences regarding stigma. Eventually the process was fine-tuned, and in December of 1994, the first “version” of “Stigma in the Mental Health Field” was piloted in Easton, Maryland, facilitated by Edgar Wiggins and Jennifer Brown. That day, the gut feeling we had that we were “on to something,” was validated as one participant tearfully revealed that she felt like a “light bulb had gone on over her head.” In the coming months, the workshop was further re-shaped, massaged, and fine-tuned. Many talented folks involved with the workgroup contributed their ideas, knowledge, and suggestions. Eventually a train-the-trainer program was started, and what began as a handful of facilitators has grown into a large and very talented cadre of trainers.
And today? Well, the workshop has grown to a series of three, each designed to build on the previous one. We now offer them not only in the state of Maryland, but around the country and even abroad. The workgroup has continued to meet, and as some folks have moved on or away, new and dedicated individuals have taken their place.
A Humbling Experience …
Even though we were anxious to teach and share what we had learned with others, and to be a part of creating a more respectful, less stigmatizing mental health system, little did we know how much more we would continue to learn. In our attempt to teach others, in fact, we were taught. In the past nine years of conducting workshops, we have had the pleasure and honor of meeting and learning from extraordinarily brave and introspective folks who have shared their life stories, looked into deep and dark places within themselves, and shared their pain and triumphs with dignity and respect.
So what lessons have we learned? Well, there have been so many that it would be beyond the scope of this article to enumerate them all (and after all, this is based on the experiences of just two of us!) but here are some overall thoughts we'd like to share.
Lesson # 1: Keep questioning your own assumptions!
Just because we are committed to doing anti-stigma work does not mean that we are “above” or “beyond” stigmatizing others. It is a constant process of self-examination.
Lesson #2: Don't underestimate the power of listening.
By this we mean truly listening, not pseudo-listening or pretending to listen. By bearing witness to the stories of others, hearing their truths, and attempting to understand, the walls created by stigmatizing attitudes and beliefs come tumbling down.
Lesson #3: Keep asking questions.
Find out the truth behind the assumptions. Learn about someone who “seems” so different from you. Forget about finding out what is “politically correct” and ask for individual truths and preferences.
Lesson #4: Take the time to get to know people as people, not as their diagnoses or as groups of people.
Stigma is similar to shorthand—it’s a quick (albeit inaccurate, damaging, and de-humanizing) way of categorizing things and people quickly. And in a climate of “there’s never enough hours in the day,” it is very tempting to fall into that trap.
All in all, it’s been a tremendous journey, and yet we have much work ahead of us. And yet, probably the most poignant and important lesson of all is:
Lesson #5: Know in your heart that change is possible.
We have seen paradigms shift, hearts open, pride and arrogance fall by the wayside, and beliefs and behaviors transform.
It is possible. It really is.

