Stigma and Neurodiversity: Inside and Out by Kris McElroy & R.J. Barna (10/15/2024)

The Anti-Stigma Project’s Refocus: Look Again campaign’s most recent Topic of the Quarter focused on the intersection of stigma, neurodivergence, and behavioral health. This topic was chosen because behavioral health conditions and neurodivergence such as autism and ADHD carry their own stigma.

Mental health problems affect approximately 70–80% of autistic individuals across all age groups, with anxiety and depression being the most common and persistent. Studies also reveal that autistic people are at a significantly increased risk of suicidality, experiencing suicidal ideation at a rate nine times higher compared to the neurotypical population. Suicide is a leading cause of early death for autistic people.

Despite the rise of awareness and public education, people with autism, ADHD, and intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD) are frequently misunderstood and misrepresented. They experience disproportionately high rates of trauma, stigma, and co-occurring mental health conditions, yet often face barriers in finding accessible mental health care that is adapted to their communication styles and needs.

Reducing stigma and increasing access to informed, affirming support systems can improve lives and present neurodivergent differences as a valuable form of diversity that has strength.

Neurodiversity 101: What Is It?

Many of us know a neurodivergent person, whether they are living with autism, ADHD, or one of the many other kinds of neurodivergence that make up our wonderfully diverse world.

While neurodiversity seems to be a growing buzzword, its meaning is still difficult for many people to define. Dr. Nick Walker, a queer autistic scholar, explains that neurodiversity is, “the infinite variation in Neuro-cognitive functioning in humans … a biological fact of our existence.” Neurodiversity, in its broadest sense, is the word we use to describe brains that function differently than what we consider “normal.”

Behavioral health encompasses a wide range of mental health issues, including neurodivergent conditions. Two examples of neurodivergence are ADHD, characterized by symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity, and autism, marked by differences in social communication and repetitive behaviors.

The more we learn about neurodiversity, the clearer it becomes that that “normal” doesn’t really exist. Still, society does have expectations about how people’s brains function, and those whose brains function differently are considered neurodivergent. And although neurodiversity is often used as a code for only autism and ADHD, this isn’t correct. Neurodivergent is an umbrella term for many other neurotypes of people who think and function differently than society expects.

The existence of Neurodiversity isn’t negative; it is just a fact. Dr. Walker provides three key principles that support this:

  • 1. Neurodiversity is a natural and valuable form of human diversity.

  • 2. There is no “normal” or “healthy” type of brain or mind. This is a cultural fiction, no more beneficial to a healthy society or to the overall well-being of humanity than the idea that there is one “normal” or “right” ethnicity, gender, or culture.

  • 3. The social dynamics that appear and connect with neurodiversity are similar to the social dynamics that appear and relate to other forms of human diversity (e.g., diversity of ethnicity, gender, or culture). These include the dynamics of social power inequalities, and also the dynamics by which diversity, when embraced, acts as a source of creative potential.

The Stigma Surrounding ADHD and Autism

Historically, mental health conditions and neurodivergence have been shrouded in ignorance and fear. For decades, autism and other forms of neurodivergence were viewed in the overall category of “mental illness” and this often led to involuntary placement in residential institutions and state hospitals (Grinker, 2020). Progress has also been made such as dismantling psychiatric state hospitals, growing initiatives to decrease stigma, and the growing understanding of diagnoses from a provider perspective, including conditions being more of a “spectrum of experience” rather than a singular rigid box as represented in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. (Grinker 2020)

Stigma surrounding mental health conditions and neurodivergence still exists. For those living with ADHD, common prejudgments include stereotypes that individuals are simply disorganized, or lack focus due to a lack of effort. For those with autism, misconceptions range from the idea that they cannot experience empathy to the oversimplification of autism as merely a set of quirky behaviors.

Such stereotypes contribute to discrimination in social settings, workplaces, and educational institutions. For example, Praslova (2021) from the Harvard Business Review reports neurodiversity discrimination is systemic, as demonstrated by the unemployment rate for autistic people in the U.S. being 85%. Praslova reports autistic people feeling like they have to work harder to understand social nuances and this impacts personal and professional relationships. Many autistic people can feel isolated, misunderstood, and discriminated against in life and at work.

It is important to note that additional intersectional factors such as race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, gender identity, and sexual orientation can add additional challenges in daily life, present barriers to accessing support, and compound experiences of both external and internal stigma.

Reducing Stigma by Adjusting Perspectives

Social dynamics and the lens through which we view our experiences and the world around us impacts how we think about behavioral health conditions and neurodiversity. According to Dr. Walker, there are two main models that society uses to engage with behavioral health, neurodiversity and disabilities: the medical model and the social model.

In the medical model, people with disabilities are viewed as needing to be fixed. Disability is considered a health condition addressed by medical professionals. It is seen as the disabled person’s problem, and the ultimate goal is to find a cure. The medical model presents disability as a tragedy, and people with disabilities as less-than, abnormal, and pitiable. It only considers people by what they cannot do and cannot be, stripping away their autonomy and potential. Disability defines and limits them.

The medical model is often seen in school settings or adult behavioral health treatment settings, where significant time is spent focusing on limitations rather than strengths and trying to force people to fit into a certain box. Insurance billing requirements also require diagnosis and evaluation through a medical model lens.

The social model of disability, on the other hand, focuses on the environment and how it impacts someone’s disability. People With Disabilities Australia describes disability from a social perspective as, “the interaction between people living with impairments, in an environment filled with physical, attitudinal, communication, and social barriers. The environment must change to enable people with impairments to participate in society on equal footing with those around them.”

According to the social model, impairments still exist, but they only cause significant problems because the person’s environment does not accommodate their needs. For example, entering a building in a wheelchair isn’t a problem unless there is no ramp. The stairs are the problem, not the person using the wheelchair.

The social model of disability emphasizes equality and empowerment. People with disabilities are just as worthy and deserving as everyone else, and those who want to support them should strive to make environments more inclusive. It encourages people to focus on their strengths and views disability as a difference, not a deficit.

Improving Support through Empowerment and Affirmation

While language and societal values are always changing, stigma and discrimination have been used for centuries to silence people and deny them a voice. Person-first language was a pivotal way to begin granting individuals with disabilities the right to be treated as a “person first,” rather than being defined by their disability, condition, or illness. Person-first language was written into law in the Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990 and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act in1997. Since then, there has been a significant rise in diagnoses of autism, ADHD, late diagnoses of autism and/or ADHD, and self-diagnoses. 

A diagnosis of autism, ADHD, or both can be life-changing. These imperfect yet specific labels can validate what neurodivergent people have sensed about themselves all along, especially by breaking down the stigma that perceives both of these conditions as a “personal failing” or “needing to be cured.” Still, there are still many challenges to receiving a diagnosis.

Devon Price highlights these challenges, including expense, diagnostic validity, and discrimination. Testing for autism and ADHD is expensive; the average cost of an autism evaluation ranges from $1,000 to $2,000, although costs can vary widely depending on insurance coverage and where you live.

Diagnostic validity has also been called into question as the tools themselves were only designed with young, white, cisgender male patients with visibly obvious symptoms in mind. He says that, “to this day, it remains very common to be turned away from even being assessed for autism for being too old, too feminine (or effeminate), too socially appropriate, too good at eye contact, too Black, too brown, or too trans. In response to these barriers, a growing number of people are using social media and knowledge from those with lived experience in online communities to diagnose themselves with autism and ADHD without a psychologist’s rubber stamp, either out of necessity, principle, or both.”

Neurodiversity Affirmative Care: Provider Perspective

Rachel Kraus at Kraus Psychotherapy LLC is one of the growing behavioral health practices providing therapy with a neurodiversity affirmative approach to improve support for all clients.

When asked a question regarding providing neurodiversity care, Kraus offers a provider perspective that supports both the individual seeking support and the provider. 

“Neurodiversity refers to the many ways our brains are wired and interact with the environment. It is essentially the ways we, as humans, show up to the world, including how we process information, sensations, and communicate.

Being neurodiversity affirmative means that we, as therapists, value one’s differences and do not place the judgments of good, bad, right, and wrong on these differences. Instead, we look at how effective one is in operating within the environment they are inhabiting. It means utilizing problem solving techniques to allow the individual to become more effective in getting to the goals they have set for themselves. Sometimes this means coaching the individual towards change and identifying barriers to that change and sometimes it means changing the environment itself. Often it is a bit of both.

Finally, being neurodiversity affirmative means a commitment to our clients and those around us to constantly be learning, expanding, and amending the way we practice therapy to be inclusive and equitable. This inherently means a commitment to being antiracist, anti-ableist, anti-heterosexist, and anti-cisgenderist. We are not perfect AND because of that, we continuously examine and re-examine our own internal bias, amending our practice to work towards these values.”

Power of Dialogue

Abbas Benmamoun, PhD, vice provost for faculty advancement at Duke University states, “You don’t have to be an expert on neurodiversity to have a conversation about neurodiversity and increase your awareness and understanding.” Benmamoun has expressed his commitment to supporting conversations and initiatives as part of a new project within the Duke Center for Autism and Brain Development to create neurodiversity-affirming teaching environments and enhance faculty understanding of neurodivergence across Duke’s schools and colleges. Benmamoun’s statement reminds us of something we can all do - engage in conversations. Conversations are the first step in empowering people to use their voices to share their experience, advocate for their needs, and collaborate to build accessible, inclusive spaces for ALL people together. 

Reducing Internal and External Stigma through Conversations

As with the stigma associated with neurodivergence and ADHD, behavioral health stigma – whether related to mental health or substance use – is all around us. We see it in media reports and dramatized depictions of people in crisis as dangerous, incapable of choice, and even criminal. We hear it in even well-meaning conversations within our personal and work relationships. We learn it from institutions and organizations, often as policy or “best practice.”

Stigma has an insidious way of infiltrating our thinking. We begin to label ourselves as, “Just a ___,” or “Less than___.” Once we start to internalize these messages, we eventually embody and project them. Using person-first language is a pivotal way to begin granting individuals with disabilities the right to be treated as a “person first,” rather than being defined by their disability, condition, or illness.

One way we continue to fight stigma – whether external or internal – is through contact and education: talking with one another to teach and learn from our unique and shared experiences. Continuing a conversation started over a decade ago, members of On Our Own of Maryland’s Anti-Stigma Project Workgroup collaborated with stigma expert Alicia Lucksted, PhD (University of Maryland School of Medicine), to update our newest workshop, An Inside Look at Stigma, available now on our public training calendar.

Acknowledgments

Thank you to the individuals and experts who shared their experiences and insights for this article. Special thanks to Dr. Nick Walker, Rachel Kraus, Sam Brandsen, and Playful Therapy Connections for their professional and scholarly contributions.

References