Each person’s experience with stigma is unique due to the diverse parts of our identities: appearances, histories, communities, cultures, and even learned perspectives. When we accept and are accepted for these aspects, we feel whole, but when harmful prejudgments become entwined with our personal identifiers, the parts no longer seem to fit and may negatively impact the whole. Being stigmatized for what should be sources of strength and pride impacts our ability to connect with ourselves, with those who prejudge us, and even with others experiencing stigma for similar reasons. When aspects of our identity become cobbled together with dual and compound stigmas, especially in regard to behavioral health, we encounter significant and unique challenges to recovery.
Threads of Stigma and Identity
The things that contribute to our identities – whether setting us apart or connecting us through similarity – can be a source of both strength and stigma. Any time we are categorized for any reason, we are forced to confront parts of ourselves associated with that category which may not align with who we are. Having been raised in gender-centric spaces (Catholic schools, Scouts, sports, etc.), my perceived “boyness,” for example, resulted in privileges both seen and unseen. I was trusted with some responsibilities and physical tasks that my sister and “girl” friends were denied. I was picked first for teams, allowed a later curfew, and even trusted with sensitive information and valuable property while being left largely undisturbed in public spaces (also a result of my skin, dress, and associations).
While my appearance provided privilege and opportunities for empowerment, it also came with the added cost of stigma and self-doubt when I failed, struggled, or expressed myself in any way that challenged the accepted social expectation (which seemed to happen more often than not). My identity became a daily test. Even within the ranks of the “Boy’s Club,” there was division as often as acceptance. My fellow boys competed with one another to be the “most boy,” sometimes through exaggerated over-performance, but more commonly by tearing down the “boyness” of others to elevate their own standing by default. Others banded together to redefine the qualities of “boy” so it more closely aligned with and elevated their own expression by way of greater numbers.
It’s easy to see that no two experiences with identity are the same, although stigma is almost always present. This situation becomes infinitely more complex when we consider the intersection and influence of other identifying aspects like socioeconomic situation, geographic location, race, sex, sexuality, and, of course, behavioral health diagnoses. When stigma impacts those with reduced choice, agency, and affirming support, the harm can be devastating to their sense of self and their likeliness to find or even seek out support.
Dual and Multiple Stigmas Entwined
Sometimes referred to as double stigma, dual and multiple stigmas are the combined result of stigma impacting two or more aspects of identity, further complicating behavioral health challenges and resulting in additional barriers to support like delayed and avoided treatment. Even affirming, privileged identifiers can carry stigma and interfere with seeking support. For me, the compound stigma drawn from American male social expectations kept me from admitting I was struggling for years.
We know this can be especially true for folks who encounter additional stressors due to “interpersonal discrimination or microaggressions, as well as internal stressors, such as internalizing stigma, concealing identity, or anticipating identity-based social rejection” (Heit, Hunger, & Rubin-McGregor, 2025). Of the almost 60 million American adults today with a mental health challenge, only 54% receive treatment and services, and it takes, on average, 10 years for us to seek them out (SAMSHA, 2023). Some refer to this as the “Decade of Silence.” Stigma is often the reason why. After all, if someone is already experiencing stigma for one or more identifying aspects, why expose yourself to another source of stress and stigma as admitting a behavioral health challenge can often be.
We also commonly see that formal systems and informal attitudes in professions can negatively impact support. A recent (2025) Reuters report on 24 commercial pilots found that - although many U.S. airlines provide pathways to confidential support and the FAA approves of some medications for treatment – pilots are unlikely to seek support for mental health challenges due to perceived stigma amongst other pilots and the potential systemic impacts on their careers. A pilot can be grounded for months or even years for disclosing any health challenge. A 2023 study cited by the article of over 5,000 U.S. and Canadian pilots found “more than half avoiding healthcare because of concerns about losing flying status. The feeling is captured by a morbid saying in the pilot community: ‘If you aren’t lying, you aren’t flying.’ ”
We may even experience compound stigma due to illnesses or conditions we may have, and the results are almost always the same in the U.S. and abroad. A 2023 study of people in a Malaysian hospital with epilepsy – which often co-occurs with depression and anxiety disorders (about 1 in 3) – found that:
Only 31.5% of people with both epilepsy and a mental health challenge agreed to mental health treatment, and of those who agreed, only 23.3% attended the appointment.
Unless referred for mental health treatment, 58.9% declined.
51.2% said stigma was the reason why they declined, while others cited self-reliance or family/caregiver disapproval (also stigma). (Fong, et al.)
Untangling Compound Stigma
Zlatke Russinova, a Sargent College research associate professor, says, “People who struggle with double stigma need to work through multiple layers of challenges. Often people blame themselves for their illness. They go into a downward spiral of self-blame and are not able to forgive themselves – but self-forgiveness is critical to achieving acceptance” (qtd. In Casanave, 2016). Considering the Stages of Change model, contemplation or acceptance, is the first step towards taking action to maintain our recovery. That action may start with choosing to focus on the strengths of one’s identities if we have been blaming ourselves for them instead.
Untangling dual and multiple stigmas begins with addressing the many strands within it. Dual stigma impacts us in different ways, and increasing our awareness of its unique expression in our own lives is key to loosening its grip over our own recovery journeys. We may not be able to eliminate stigma entirely, especially as it may be interwoven into the empowering aspects of our identities, but by better understanding it, we can reclaim more space for healing, acceptance, and self-directed recovery in our lives and the lives of those we are supporting.
Sources
Fong, Si-Lei, et al. (2025, February). “Double Stigma: Reluctance to be referred to a psychiatrist among people with epilepsy and psychiatric comorbidities, Epilepsy & Behavior. Volume 163. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S152550502400578X
Heitt, J., et al. (2025, August 26). “Multiple marginalized identities, minority stress, and mental health.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass. Volume 19, Issue 8. https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/spc3.70077
Maio, H. A. (2016, November 22). Dealing with double stigma: The brink. Boston University. https://www.bu.edu/articles/2016/dealing-with-double-stigma/
SAMSHA (2023). “Highlights for the 2023 National Survey on Drug Use and health.” https://www.samhsa.gov/data/sites/default/files/NSDUH%202023%20Annual%20Release/2023-nsduh-main-highlights.pdf
Singh, R. K., & Catchpole, D. (n.d.). “‘If you aren’t lying, you aren’t flying.’ Airline pilots hide mental health struggles.” Reuters. www.reuters.com/investigations/if-you-arent-lying-you-arent-flying-airline-pilots-hide-mental-health-struggles-2025-12-03/

