5 Anti-Stigma Tips for Constructive Conversations by R.J. Barna (4/2/2025)

For the past few months, our Refocus: Look Again campaign has explored the impact of language on behavioral health stigma, sharing articles that highlight the ways language shapes perceptions and creates both opportunities and obstacles for recovery. Use of derogatory or outdated terms can reinforce harmful stereotypes, leading to discrimination, isolation, and reluctance to seek support. Conversely, sharing a common language of identity and experience – meeting others where they are – can enhance recovery outcomes, especially when ongoing conversations include the insights of both sides. And that’s true of being productive in just about any conversation.

Professional and cultural norms often limit and discourage open discussions, particularly about difficult topics, but even so-called “easy conversations” can present challenges. Exchanging ideas to reach a shared understanding through common language is a complex process. Ferdinand de Saussure, a Swiss linguist (1857–1913), identified that speech and understanding rely on three components: the idea (signifier), the word (signified), and the meaning (sign).

What comes to mind when a friend says, “A storm is coming?” The simple word “storm” may evoke different meanings based on expectations and experience. For example, if it’s windy, you might expect a tornado, or a blizzard if it’s winter. If you’re near the coast, you might think of a hurricane, or an X-Men character at a comic convention. Maybe your friend is actually referring to an old injury, meaning to convey, “My knee hurts,” due to a felt change in the weather.

When we talk to one another, even exchanging the same common words, we rarely share the same ideas or arrive at common meaning. By talking with one another, we explore ideas more deeply and negotiate meaning, arriving at a clearer understanding of one another. Although this can be difficult, especially when discussing complex, polarizing, or potentially stigmatizing topics, current (2022) research shows that although most people agree conversations are hard, we’re not as bad at them as we expect.

Here are 5 tips for starting and maintaining meaningful conversations, even when it’s difficult.

1. Show genuine interest in your questions and answers; be present, thoughtful, and curious

Sometimes, starting or invigorating a conversation is as simple as pointing out something you like about someone, whether that’s their shoes, haircut, taste in music, or a quality like honesty or creativity. Saying, “I love your hat! Where did you get it?” can open a conversation. “I love that perspective! Can you tell me more?” keeps it going. Be mindful of power dynamics and boundaries, however; a comment about someone’s appearance may be unwelcome or even inappropriate.

One-word replies devastate conversations. I regret many missed opportunities with my parents after school, responding to their inquiries with, “nothing,” “fine,” or “good.” To provide opportunities that keep conversations going, include “threads” for follow-up. When my mother asked, “How was school today?” I could have instead replied, “Alright. We had tacos and a math test,” which would give her options to ask, “Were they better than mine?” or “How did it go?”

2. Choose your words carefully and respectfully, using “I” and “We” over “You”

It’s easy to turn against one another when perspectives and positions differ. The solution may be as easy as choosing “I” or “We” over “You,” exploring possibilities together rather than being on the attack or defense. Instead of saying, “You did this,” which reasonably will lead to someone feeling defensive, try, “When I hear that, I feel…” This approach helps you speak in specifics, not generalities, like, “You always do that.” Generalities lead to stereotypes and stigmatizing views, assuming “You” are all alike. Additionally, consider creating solutions together by asking, “What can we do about this?

3. Active and reflective listening – when it’s possible

Active listening, thoughtful questions, and engaged body language can make others feel valued and understood. Sometimes, repeating what you’ve heard in your own words helps demonstrate listening and ensures continued understanding. Consider replying, “What I’m hearing is …” or “It sounds like you’re saying …” and see if they agree. And if there is a disconnect, try “Can you help me to understand?” Stigma or other social dynamics may interrupt our ability to fully agree on a shared meaning, so it’s important to recognize when it may not be the best time to continue a conversation. You can always say, “Can we come back to this? I need some time to reflect on what we’ve said.”

4. Consider conversational layers – what happened, how we feel about that, and how that intersects/ threatens identity

Conversations have layers: the words themselves, our reaction to them, and how the perceived meaning impacts our sense of self/identity. Conversations that touch on identity are understandably personal and can feel threatening, especially when stigmatizing assumptions are present or perceived. If one of these layers is unexpectedly uncovered, check in and see if a pause or clarification is needed. Ask, “How has this impacted you personally?” or “What does this mean to you?” from a place of genuine curiosity.

5. Refocus: Look Again

Regularly check in with yourself and the person you’re talking with, ensuring that you’re both discussing the same ideas, words, and meanings in the same ways and with equitable contributions. Inevitably, comments and reactions will take us in unexpected directions, but that’s fine if it’s a choice we make together. When we find ourselves out of alignment, we may need to re-define the purpose, refocus the point of our conversation, and look again at ways to move forward together in positive and mutually beneficial ways.

Communication is incredible and complex, and so are we for taking part in that process. Whether formal or informal, casual or deeply personal, employing these strategies can lead to stronger connections and yield productive and respectful conversations. ν

Look for upcoming sessions of our workshop Stigma: Language Matters at onourownmd.org

Sources and Additional Reading

Talking to strangers: A week-long intervention reduces psychological barriers to social connection. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, Volume 102, September 2022. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022103122000750

Use these 7 phrases to make new friends at any age, says psychologist and expert in human connection. CNBC. April 2024. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/04/23/what-to-say-to-make-new-friends-at-any-age-from-psychologist.html

To avoid “awkward, superficial” small talk, make one little change, says communication expert. CNBC. February 2025. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/17/avoid-awkward-superficial-small-talk-make-one-little-change-communication-expert.html

What is active listening? Harvard Business Review. January 2024. https://hbr.org/2024/01/what-is-active-listening